I might write for a living, but the idea of sharing words aloud in front of others still makes my stomach churn. I get nervous enough as it is just making videos to post.
I’m not alone in that. There’s a reason we’re afraid of public speaking more than death: What if we mess up and they hate us and we’re alone forever and lose everything and —
…it’s not exactly a feeling of safety.

But in professional settings, at some point, the odds of being asked to present something — especially in leadership positions — is high. As we try to meet this expectation to communicate, paraphrasing the text we cram onto slides feels like a security blanket. The text can still anchor us enough to make the anxiety bearable, and because we’re not reading verbatim, we give a more positive impression that we’ve internalized the message.
But what if paraphrasing is just as bad as reading verbatim?
It pretty much is, according to neuroscience.
In my latest edition of Mind Uncensored, I discuss cognitive load and related principles to show why abandoning paraphrasing in favor of image-based slides really is best.
Yes, it means you have to prepare differently. But if it means the audience is actually going to remember and understand what we say, isn’t that worth it?
Why Paraphrasing Your Slide Text Doesn’t Work (and What to Do Instead)

Most of us have gotten the memo that reading verbatim from PowerPoint slides isn’t the greatest dish we could serve at the potluck. We can read faster than we can talk, so the presenter usually finishes speaking the slide after we’ve already read it, leaving us bored, annoyed, and not really listening. The irritation is magnified if the presentation doesn’t include anything else but the slides, since we know we could have whipped through them on our own without the presenter’s handholding.
But talking over your slides — chattering something different than the text that’s visible on the screen — is just as bad as reading them word for word. Neuroscience suggests that, for real power and memorability, the best approach ensures that what you say isn’t competing with what people see, using multiple processing channels in the brain at once.
What we know from cognitive load principles
When we look at how the brain processes information, multiple theories support the rationale for ditching the paraphrase-over-text presentation approach.
The first concept is the redundancy effect and cognitive load theory. Studies in multimedia learning show that if we present identical information in both visual text and spoken words, comprehension goes down while extraneous cognitive load goes up. That means that, when we force people to divide their attention between two forms of the same message, the audience will struggle to understand and remember the message, as the brain spends more energy trying to make sense of everything.
This relates closely to the split-attention or spatial contiguity effect, which sits inside cognitive load theory. When we have to divide our attention between separate sources of related information, the brain has to jump back and forth between separate elements. If you are showing a slide with bullet points as you paraphrase the points, the audience is simultaneously handling a visual-linguistic task (reading) and an auditory-linguistic task (listening). Both these tasks rely on language processing, so they compete for the same cognitive resources. Because the brain can’t effectively process two strings of linguistic input at once, comprehension suffers.
The modality effect is also at play. This is a cognitive science principle that says people learn better when information is split between different senses — like hearing and seeing — rather than overloaded in just one. When you put a lot of text on a slide and talk over it, you’re forcing your audience to use their verbal processing system for both reading and listening at the same time. That creates confusion and mental strain. If you instead use a simple image or graphic while you speak, the brain can divide the work — your voice through the auditory channel and the visual through the visual channel — so it’s easier to understand and remember what you’re saying.
If paraphrasing over text on slides stinks, why do we do it?
In high-pressure situations like presentations, paraphrasing can feel like the best of both worlds. We get to cling to the information we’ve prepared that’s written down, which helps us to feel safe and less stressed out. Maintaining content density also gives the impression that the presentation is of a higher value, simply because we equate more with better.
At the same time, paraphrasing isn’t verbatim. It offers the illusion that we are relaxed enough to present in a more spontaneous or on-the-fly style.
But the irony is that the more we cram in and talk over, the less people retain. And if we’re constantly pivoting back and forth from looking at the slides for cues to looking at the audience, the confusion they feel about how focused you really are on them — which immediately creates disconnect — is real.
When you trust, you get polish
Effective communication requires trusting the audience — simplifying visuals, pausing to let them read when needed, or letting what you say carry the message while the slides simply support. And the best presenters aren’t the ones who say the most — they’re the ones who help the audience understand the most.
So, if you want your message to land, focus on clarity, not performance. Instead of trying to control, aim to connect. When you let your slides breathe, allow your voice to lead, and trust that your message is stronger when you deliver it with intention, your audience naturally will receive an exceptionally polished version of what you came to say.
The original version of this post appeared in Wanda Thibodeaux’s Mind Uncensored newsletter August 14, 2025. Like this content? Subscribe to Mind Uncensored!
Subscribe on LinkedIn