You work hard, but you won’t be half as productive as you could be if you’ve always got conflicts with those around you.

I get it if you’ve been pulling out your “I” statements to prevent or cool heated conversations. Pretty much every psychologist on the planet is going to tell you to use them because of the way they encourage you to express your feelings and shift the focus away from the other person.
But did you know that “I” statements can go haywire?
In fact, the way “I” statements shift the focus to you can be a problem.
I once had an acquaintance respond with a fiery, “We’re not talking about you!” when I tried to apply an “I” statement.
“I” statements can make the other person feel like you’re not considering them at all, even if you are.
I won’t tell you NEVER to use “I” statements. But you have to approach them mindfully with caution.
If you’re tired of tension with your colleagues or loved ones, this week’s Mind Uncensored newsletter gives more details on how others can misinterpret the “I” statements you use. Using the alternatives and tips at the end of the edition might support the relationships you want and need to have.
Why “I” Statements Don’t Always Work (and What to Say Instead)

Whether your coworker is stinking up the break room with their tuna sandwiches or your boss is being a jerkface by steamrolling you in meetings, the conflicts you have at work probably don’t do your blood pressure any favors. Wouldn’t it be fantastic if you didn’t have to walk around those landmines every day?
The solution, according to plenty of psychologists, is to use plenty of “I” language. For instance, instead of saying, “You make the whole breakroom smell like a sh-tty fishery!”, say “I feel nauseated by the stench of your meal.”
Wait.
Does the second version still come across as a little offensive?
You can almost hear the thought process.
What do they mean, “Stench of my meal?!“
The limitations of “I” statements
Psychologists argue that “I” language diffuses conflict by focusing on the speaker, not the listener. It’s supposed to make the listener feel less attacked and make them more willing to hear you out without them turning into this guy:

But as my example above shows, you can use I language and still trigger a negative, defensive reaction in your listener if the I statement still includes judgments or other barbs.
But the principle can apply even if your “I” statements are objectively stated facts (e.g., “I feel disregarded when you bring your tuna because the smell bothers me.”).
Let’s look at a classic show to dissect what I mean.
One of the longest-running series on television is A&E’s Intervention — it first ran in 2005 and is in its 25th season as I write. The whole premise of the show is to get someone with some kind of addiction problem to get treatment.
As part of the sequence for the show, nearly every episode features a scene where the addict’s loved ones gather around and deliver a barrage of “I” statements to let the addict know how they’ve influenced others.
And in maaaaaany episodes, what happens?
The addict bolts out of the room faster than…(wait for it)…Usain Bolt.
“I” statements can accurately relate how the speaker is feeling or what the situation is. But the addict still bolts because they mentally focus on and emotionally react not to the speaker’s expression of feeling or impact, but to the fact they’ve done something wrong, offended others, or otherwise created a problem.
Nobody likes to feel like they’ve messed up.
Now keep in mind that “I” statements often don’t present a way forward — they’re just statements of a current issue, influence, and feeling. Nobody likes to feel like they’ve messed up and now have to figure out how to clean up the mess alone. In the case of Intervention, loved ones do present a solution (treatment), but it’s their solution the addict hasn’t had the chance to give input on, and the way it’s presented (one person against many) can worsen the sense of error and lack of control.
But this is only one side of the coin.
In a previous newsletter, I explored how pivoting to your own experiences can be a poor way to show empathy. If you’re not careful, it can interrupt the other person’s narrative and expression and refocuses the conversation on you. That leaves the other person feeling alienated and unheard.
Using “I” statements during a work or personal conflict can have a similar effect. Even if the other person doesn’t get stuck in the idea they’ve flubbed and are going to need to make some corrections, they can hear your “I” statements and think, “Why is this entirely about you?” (e.g., “Why doesn’t it matter that I really enjoy tuna? Are you just not going to think about what I might want?”).
Moving beyond the classic “I” statement recommendation
As you might deduce from the above scenarios,
resolving conflicts isn’t dependent on formulaic “I” statements, but rather on communicating a sense of togetherness and potential in a way that honors your authenticity.
Saying, “I feel disregarded when you bring your tuna because the smell bothers me,” is different than saying, “I’m really glad you have meals you like, but because the smell is strong, can we find another area for you to heat it up?” The first statement focuses solely on a negative impact. The second starts with something positive and notes the issue with an invitation to collaborate on a solution.
You also could try this tactic — present the solution you see as a favor the other person can do, such as, “Would you help me out and see if there’s another place to heat your fish? You’d make the smell of that healthy sandwich you’ve got easier for me to handle.” By asking for a favor, you give the impression that you trust the other person and can actually make them like you better, as I detail in this newsletter. This version can be disarming because concept of helping implies desired connection. There’s also a clear presentation of action to take without an overt focus on the negative.
You can talk about you, but don’t forget “we”
None of this means you can’t talk about how someone is making you feel or the damage they’re delivering — I’m not an advocate of suppression and people pleasing. It just means that, as you express your own emotions and needs, you stay mindful of how your message will land and communicate in a way that offers hope for making progress together.
Remember the three strategies I offered in the newsletter about showing empathy:
- Ask good, inviting questions that make it clear you want to know more.
- Directly tell the other person you’d like to understand or explain why you value the perspectives they have to offer.
- Ask the other person to verify whether you’re interpreting them correctly (e.g., “It sounds like…”; “Is [your interpretation of their thoughts, actions, or situation] accurate?”).
If you must use an “I” statement, including “we” (e.g., “I’m a little nervous, so do you think we could…”) is a simple way to improve the odds it will land better. If you really want to build a deep connection and are comfortable, include the explanation or “why” behind your feeling (e.g., “I’m a little nervous because I once had a boss who…”). Just make sure to pivot right back to the collaborative solution so the conversation stays present-oriented and the other person doesn’t feel like you’re trying to pull all the focus to you.
The original version of this post appeared in Wanda Thibodeaux’s Mind Uncensored newsletter February 27, 2025. Like this content? Subscribe to Mind Uncensored!
Subscribe on LinkedIn